|
God
and Buddha:
A dialogue between Deepak Chopra and Robert Thurman
Raja
and I attended a dialogue held at Tibet House New York in December
1999 between Robert Thurman and Deepak Chopra. They were to explore
the ultimate harmonies and differences between Buddhism and Vedanta,
the most universal concepts behind Hinduism. They described how
both the Rishis, the ancient sages of India, and the Buddha, the
Enlightened One, taught the way to freedom from suffering and also
revealed their insights into the truth that lay behind all things.
Hinduism
believes that behind the cosmic veil, behind all the layers that
form this illusion of the Universe, or Maya, lies a supreme intelligence
called Brahman or God. The word Brahman comes from the root sound
Brah - which means pure energy. That Intelligence is prevalent throughout
the Universe in everything and is mainfest everywhere. Hinduism
sets out that Brahman is also within each of us in the form of Atman
or our souls, and that we are actually that which we seek. The pursuit
of Hinduism is to go beyond the veil and realize that you and the
creator are one and the same: Tat Tvam Asi - Thou art that.
Buddhism
is very similar in it's precepts but takes the further step that
when we realize enlightenment, we find there is no God, no Brahman,
just a superconscious self which is a universalized version of our
own little self. The pursuit of Buddhism is to go from the small
self to a realization of the Buddha self in each of us and then
to realize that suffering and the pains of life are in our own interactions
with the world and can be transcended through Buddha realization
and the following of a prescribed path.
The
gathering at Tibet House was an impressive crowd of New York's most
imminent and influential seekers and the atmosphere that evening
was conducive to a spiritual conversation between two of the foremost
thinkers in the west on Mind, Body and Spirit. The evening started
out with both Chopra and Thurman taking 10 minutes each to outline
the precepts of Vedanta and Buddhism. As the evening progressed
Thurman expresses that Buddha was also a Vedantist in nature except
that the language which described the transcendantal experience
was the only real differentaitor between these two major schools
of thought. At the end of it all, both paths agreed upon one fundamental
thing, that the universe we observe around us is a creation of our
minds, and that if we can work within any tradition to become universal
in our thinking, then we will transcend all the limitations and
sufferings of this reality and realize that our true nature is out
there with the stars. Then we will look at each other with new eyes
and the world will change as a result.
As
my first opportunity to see either of them, I was simultaneously
pleased and also slightly disappointed by their interchange. Both
were very charismatic, as you would imagine, but their manners varied
to a wide extent, maybe reflecting the differences between the cultures.
Deepak Chopra was extremely well prepared in presenting the fundamental
qualities that characterize Vedanta as a magical projection of divine
consciousness that we all share, not coincidentally because he had
just written a book about this very subject. Then, Robert Thurman
presented the Buddhism viewpoint that was highly idiosyncratic and
humorous, but it seemed to me that he was less apt (or less interested)
in presenting the fundamentals. He seemed to get enwrapped in his
own stories and anecdotes rather than provide the missing (and necessary)
half of the dialogue. Not that it was important that they go for
contrast rather than the obvious similarities between the two major
Indian religions, but there seemed a deference given by Thurman
that was not reciprocated by Chopra. This potentially powerful interaction
was a bit less potent than it could have been, although it was still
a very valuable start.
It
was clear how fundamental both Vedanta and Buddhism are to understanding
and liberating our being and our selves. Buddhism particularly teaches
the total awareness of reality, awareness that embraces our ultimate
oneness and our relative, or virtual individuality. When we know
we are God, we connect to all beings through Buddhahood. Science
and poetry meet in the mantra Ð OM MANI PADME HUM.
"Love
is the ultimate truth at the heart of creation. We are all the same
being in different disguises. If I start to peel the layers of my
soul, I begin to go beyond my constricted fabricated self and discover
who I really am." Ð DEEPAK CHOPRA
"It
comes from India, the idea that we can know our way free from suffering.
Our actual birthright as human beings is that we have the right
to be in love with all beings, the entire universe, all the time.
God means being in love with everything." Ð ROBERT THURMAN
DEEPAK
CHOPRA, a physician and expert in mind/body medicine, is the author
of the recently published How To Know God, and numerous other best
sellers, including The Seven Spiritual Laws of Success, Ageless
Body Timeless Mind, Quantum Healing. You can visit Deepak Chopra
on-line at http://www.chopra.com
ROBERT
THURMAN, Professor of Religion at Columbia University and a close
associate of the Dalai Lama, is one of the foremost spokesmen for
Buddhism and Tibet and is also the founder of Tibet House in New
York.. His books include Inner Revolution, Circling the Sacred Mountain
and a translation of The Tibetan Book of the Dead. You can visit
Tibet House on-line at http://www.tibethouse.org/
The
dialogue was a co-production of Tibet House New York and Mystic
Fire Video. Produced and directed by Sheldon Rochlin, edited by
Maxine Harris and Sheldon Rochlin. You can watch video clips of
this dialogue or purchase the video that has just been released
by going to Mystic Fire's Web site at http://www.mysticfire.com
A T
Mann
April 2000
|